How to prepare for SSDI hearing in New York?

By Hogan Smith

Updated 07/18/2025


If your Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) claim has been denied in New York, requesting a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) is a crucial opportunity to present your case in detail. Being thoroughly prepared can significantly improve your chances of winning benefits.

Find out if you qualify for SSDI benefits. Pre-qualify in 60 seconds for up to $4,018 per month and 12 months back pay.

Please answer a few questions to help us determine your eligibility.


1. Know What to Expect at the Hearing

During your hearing:


  • You will testify under oath about your medical conditions, symptoms, daily limitations, and work history
  • The ALJ will ask questions to clarify how your disability prevents you from working
  • A vocational expert (VE) may be present to testify about whether you can perform any type of work
  • Your attorney or representative, if you have one, will present arguments on your behalf and may ask you additional questions to strengthen your case


2. Review Your Social Security File

Before the hearing, it is essential to:


  • Request and review your complete Social Security file
  • Understand why your claim was denied
  • Identify missing or outdated medical records that need to be updated before your hearing date


3. Gather Updated Medical Evidence

Strong, up-to-date medical records are critical to your success:


  • Obtain recent treatment notes, specialist evaluations, test results, and imaging studies
  • Ask your doctor for a detailed medical source statement describing your diagnosis, symptoms, treatment plan, and how your condition limits your ability to work
  • Include reports from all treating providers, such as mental health counselors, physical therapists, and specialists


4. Prepare Your Testimony

Think carefully about how your medical condition affects your daily life. Be ready to answer:


  • What symptoms do you experience, and how often?
  • What activities are difficult or impossible for you?
  • Why did you stop working, and what prevents you from working now?
  • How do you manage daily living tasks, such as bathing, cooking, or household chores?


Provide specific examples instead of general statements to illustrate your struggles clearly.


5. Practice Before the Hearing

If you have an attorney, they will prepare you by:


  • Conducting mock hearing questions to build your confidence
  • Ensuring your testimony is clear, honest, and consistent with your medical records


Practicing helps reduce nervousness and ensures you communicate your limitations effectively.


6. Plan Logistically for the Hearing

On your hearing day:


  • Arrive at least 30 minutes early if in person, or ensure your phone or computer is ready if it’s held virtually
  • Dress neatly in comfortable clothing
  • Bring a valid photo ID and any notes to help remember key details
  • Ensure you are in a quiet, private space if your hearing is conducted by phone or video


7. Consider Bringing a Witness

Having a spouse, family member, or caregiver testify about your daily struggles can strengthen your case. Discuss with your attorney whether a witness will add value to your hearing.

How Hogan Smith Can Help You

At Hogan Smith, we assist New York residents through every stage of their disability hearing by:


  • Reviewing your complete case file to identify weaknesses and missing evidence
  • Gathering strong medical records and statements to support your claim
  • Preparing you thoroughly for testimony so you feel confident and ready
  • Representing you effectively at the hearing, presenting your case clearly and persuasively

Contact Hogan Smith Today

If you have an upcoming SSDI hearing in New York, don’t go through it alone. Contact Hogan Smith today for a free consultation. We’ll make sure you are fully prepared to secure the disability benefits you deserve.


Further Reading

A black and white icon of a newspaper on a white background.

Updated February 10, 2025

A black and white icon of a newspaper on a white background.

Updated February 10, 2025

A black and white icon of a newspaper on a white background.

Updated February 10, 2025

Was this helpful?

Boost Your Chance of Being Approved

Get the Compensation You Deserve

Our experts have helped thousands like you get cash benefits.

Contact Us


How It Works
A black and white drawing of a checklist and a handshake.
1

Briefly tell us about your case

A stack of papers with lines on them on a white background.
2

Provide your contact information

A black and white icon of a scale of justice and a briefcase.
3

Choose attorneys to contact you