How to prepare for an SSDI hearing in New York?

By Hogan Smith

Updated 08/15/2025


An SSDI hearing is often your best chance to win benefits after an initial denial. In New York, these hearings take place before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) and are less formal than a courtroom trial—but preparation is key. The better you prepare, the stronger your case will be.

Find out if you qualify for SSDI benefits. Pre-qualify in 60 seconds for up to $4,018 per month and 12 months back pay.

Please answer a few questions to help us determine your eligibility.


1. Know What to Expect at the Hearing

An SSDI hearing usually lasts between 45 minutes to an hour and may be held in person, by video, or by phone. You, your representative, and sometimes vocational or medical experts will be present. The ALJ will ask about:


  • Your medical conditions and how they affect daily life.
  • Your work history and why you can no longer perform those jobs.
  • Your treatment efforts and compliance with medical advice.


2. Review Your Case File in Advance

Request a copy of your SSA file before the hearing. Go over:


  • Medical records to ensure they are complete and up to date.
  • Work history reports to confirm accuracy.
  • Any previous SSA notes that might influence the judge’s view.


3. Strengthen Your Medical Evidence

A strong case is built on solid medical proof. Make sure to:


  • Submit recent doctor’s notes, test results, and treatment plans.
  • Obtain statements from your physicians describing your limitations in detail.
  • Include evidence of ongoing treatment to show that your condition is persistent.


4. Practice Your Testimony

The judge will want to hear your own words about your limitations. You should:


  • Be honest and specific—avoid vague answers like “I can’t do anything.”
  • Use examples from daily life, such as “I can only stand for 10 minutes before my back pain forces me to sit.”
  • Avoid exaggeration, but also don’t minimize your struggles.


5. Prepare for Vocational Expert Questions

In many New York hearings, a vocational expert (VE) will testify about jobs you might still be able to do. Your representative can challenge the VE’s conclusions, but you should be ready to explain why you can’t perform certain work.


6. Address New York–Specific Factors
  • Hearing wait times in cities like New York City, Albany, and Buffalo can be long, so be ready to update medical records before your date.
  • Local judges may have different questioning styles—an attorney familiar with your hearing office can help you prepare for that.

How Hogan Smith Can Help You

Hogan Smith can guide you step-by-step through the SSDI hearing process in New York by:


  • Reviewing and organizing your entire case file.
  • Gathering medical opinions that directly address SSA’s disability criteria.
  • Preparing you through mock hearings so you know exactly what to expect.
  • Cross-examining vocational and medical experts to strengthen your case.
  • Following up with SSA to make sure all evidence is properly filed before the hearing.

Contact Hogan Smith Today

Winning an SSDI hearing in New York often depends on how well you prepare. Hogan Smith takes a proactive approach—ensuring your medical records are airtight, your testimony is clear, and your legal arguments are persuasive. We will work closely with you so you walk into your hearing confident and ready. Call us today to get started on building the strongest case possible.


Further Reading

A black and white icon of a newspaper on a white background.

Updated February 10, 2025

A black and white icon of a newspaper on a white background.

Updated February 10, 2025

A black and white icon of a newspaper on a white background.

Updated February 10, 2025

Was this helpful?

Boost Your Chance of Being Approved

Get the Compensation You Deserve

Our experts have helped thousands like you get cash benefits.

Contact Us


How It Works
A black and white drawing of a checklist and a handshake.
1

Briefly tell us about your case

A stack of papers with lines on them on a white background.
2

Provide your contact information

A black and white icon of a scale of justice and a briefcase.
3

Choose attorneys to contact you